Triple Chip Brown Butter Cookies

304
     When looking over the cookie plate, do you ever try to spy the cookie bursting with the most chips?  If you do, then these are the perfect cookies for you!  Ooh la la!  Triple chip brown butter cookies!  What more could you ask for?  (Unless, of course, you were craving brownies or cupcakes.)

Have you ever had butterscotch chips?  I had never had them until I made these cookies.  I’ve been deprived my whole life!   If you’ve never had butterscotch chips, please, go buy a bag.  I’m telling you this as a friend!  If you’re already a butterscotch-chip-lover, let’s hang out soon.  Oh, and in case you were wondering, brown butter only makes the butterscotch flavor better 🙂

     If you make these cookies–which I highly encourage you to do–don’t be alarmed by the amount of chips in the dough.  The first time I made them, I didn’t think the cookies would be able to hold together.  I even had to scoop loose chips out of the bottom of the bowl and pack them into the dough because there were so many.  That’s all part of the beauty of these cookies, though.  Chips, chips, and more chips!  Not only will your cookies hold together, but they will be that much better for the chips popping out of every surface.

Normally, I wouldn’t encourage you to use just one kind of chocolate when you could use two, but I really couldn’t tell the difference between the semisweet chocolate and the dark chocolate chips. There were so many crowded together that they all just tasted chocolate-y.  That’s not a bad thing, but I think you could get away with just using one kind of chip if you didn’t feel like buying two different kinds and having two open bags.  Someone suggested making these with white chocolate and dark chocolate.  I’ve never tried that, but it sounds good.

P.S.  When I brown butter, I like to swirl the pan slowly and continuously once the butter is mostly melted.  It’s a little hard on the wrist, but I’ve never had a problem with the butter burning.

Advertisements

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

073

     Hello!  I know it’s been a while since we’ve seen each other, but I have a new cookie recipe absolutely too fabulous to keep to myself.  Let’s skip the catch-up chitchat (Chit chat?  Chit-chat?) and just talk.  Let’s talk about white chocolate macadamia nut cookies.

     Have you ever had Subway’s white chocolate macadamia nut cookies?  Are they your favorite part about going to Subway?  Well, forget about them!  I, too, am a lover of Subway’s cookies (Oddly enough, they are some of the very few store bought cookies I like), but Subway’s cookies have never caused my eyes to roll back into my head in bliss.  I’ve never exclaimed,

     “Oh. My. Gosh,” after the first bite of one of their cookies.  Just please make these.  You’ll know what I mean!

     These white chocolate macadamia nut cookies are buttery and crispy around the corners but tender in the middle.  They are vanilla-y and white chocolate-y and nutty.  Actually, macadamia nuts have kind of a mild flavor.  I guess these aren’t super nutty after all.  They’re pleasantly nutty, though.  I’m getting off on a tangent.  I apologize.

     All you need is one bite of a cookie to make you want the whole batch pan.  Let’s not forget how they make your house smell, too.  Two different people came to the house while I was baking these and immediately exclaimed,

     “Wow!  It smells amazing in here!”  When I offered them a cookie, they both had the same eyes-rolling-into-the-back-of-their-heads reaction that I did.  Success!

     I baked up a batch of room temperature dough and a batch of dough that had been refrigerated overnight.  While I found it easier to gauge the doneness of the room temperature dough cookies, the refrigerated dough cookies baked up golden, craggy, and visibly bursting with white chocolate and macadamia nuts.  Baked both ways, the cookies taste fantastic.  I personally liked how the chilled-dough cookies looked better, but the other ones were still extremely pretty.  They were just smoother and not as tell-tale of the glory hidden inside of them.

     I baked the chilled-dough cookies until they were golden brown around the edges and had patches of golden brown on top.  The tops had a shiny, done-looking crust that held up when pressed lightly with my fingertip.  I could still feel some softness underneath.  In my oven (turned down a little over twenty-five degrees), I ended up baking each pan for about ten and a half minutes, rotating the pan halfway through.

     I baked the room-temperature dough cookies until they were golden around the edges and lightly golden on top with darker patches beginning to turn golden brown.  When pressed lightly, they felt puffy and soft.  Each pan spent about nine minutes in the oven, getting rotated about halfway through baking.

     I know (at least around my house) macadamia nuts can sometimes be a little hard to track down.  I found Diamond chopped macadamia nuts sold in ½ cup packages in the baking aisle at Target.  Even though the nuts were already chopped, I ended up chopping them a little more since some of the nuts appeared to be whole.  I also, as always, bought three (four ounce) white chocolate baking bars and roughly chopped them instead of using the “white” chips sold at my supermarket.

     I could continue to enumerate on the deliciousness of these cookies, but, as Briscoe Darling would say, eating speaks louder than words.  These white chocolate macadamia cookies are disappearing fast!

Snickers Brookie Muffins

IMG_2322

     I’m back from my unintentional holiday hiatus from blogging.  Now that it’s 2014, and things have settled down, I felt inspired to snap my 50mm prime back on my camera and photograph these little treats.  I hope all of your holidays were lovely and blessed!

     Well, I finally did it!  I finally made brookie muffins!  I can’t believe I’ve waited this long to make these.  I mean, brownies and cookies in the same dessert?  Come on!  What have I been waiting for?  To make the brookies even more fun (and tasty), the cookie dough isn’t just chocolate chip cookie dough, but peanut butter chip and chocolate chip cookie dough.  For an extra twist, I chopped up Snickers I had in the pantry and threw those in the middle of the muffins.  Ahh, bliss!

     You might have some cookie dough left over.  If you do, you can bake up a tray of cookies (Yay!  Another pan to wash!), or wrap up the dough and put it in the refrigerator or the freezer for a small cookie dough emergency.  When I made these, I made the full amount of cookie dough from the original recipe and had a lot left over.  For this post, I roughly halved the original recipe.

     (Oh, if you’re wondering why there are flecks of espresso in the cookie part of the muffin in the picture, it’s because I originally added the espresso to the cookie dough.  I think it would be better in the brownie batter, though, which is why I switched it in my recipe.)

For the cookies:

1 stick unsalted butter, softened

½ cup granulated sugar

¼ cup brown sugar

1 large egg

½ tbs. pure vanilla extract

1 cup all-purpose flour

½ tsp. baking soda

½ tsp. salt

5 ounces (half a bag) peanut butter chips

6 ounces (half a bag) mini or regular semisweet chocolate chips

9 snack-size Snickers

For the brownies:

1 box Pillsbury family size brownie mix

½ tbs. espresso powder

½ cup oil

¼ cup water

2 eggs

  Preheat the oven to 350˚ (I had the oven a little below 325˚, probably around 315˚.)  Grease two muffins pans with shortening and set aside.  Halve Snickers lengthwise and then quarter widthwise (You’ll end up with eight small-ish Snickers chunks.)  Prepare the brownie batter according to the box’s directions, except for adding ½ tbs. of instant espresso powder to the batter.

     In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream the butter and sugars on medium speed until lightened in color and fluffy, about three minutes.  Add the egg and vanilla and mix well.  In a separate bowl, whisk together the flour, baking soda, and salt.  Add the dry ingredients in two additions to the mixer, mixing until just combined.  Add the chocolate and the peanut butter chips to the dough and combine.

       Fill each well of the muffin tin about halfway up the sides with brownie batter (I filled each well with a 1 ½ tbs. cookie scoop full of batter)  Place three Snickers chunks in the center of each well on top of the brownie batter.  Scoop a rounded tablespoon of cookie dough, roll into a ball, and then flatten the dough into a disc between your palms.  Lay the disc over the top of the brownie batter.  Repeat until the entire pan is finished.

     Pop the muffin pan into the oven for twelve to fifteen minutes, rotating halfway through.  The brookie muffins are done when the cookie dough is golden brown around the edges yet has a hint of softness in the middle.  Let the brookies cool completely before trying to remove them from the pan.  The centers may collapse inward as the muffins cool.

     Once the brookie muffins are cooled, use the thin edge of a silicone spatula to work around the edges and loosen the muffins.  After the muffins are loosened, slip the edge of the spatula down to the bottom of the pan and gently try to pop the muffins out of the pan.  If they continue to stick, just keep working around the edge with the spatula.  Sometimes the muffins split in half.  That’s okay.  Just set the top back on the bottom; it will still be delicious.  You can even use those split muffins to make ice cream sandwiches.

     If you want to serve this warm with ice cream, I would suggest under-baking the muffins a little so that the middle is soft and gooey.  Then, scoop the muffin out of the pan (It will probably fall apart.), top with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, and drizzle with hot fudge.

 Adapted from Blue-Eyed Bakers

Cookies ‘n’ Cream Chocolate Blossoms

IMG_1581

     Who knew that Hershey’s sells cookies ‘n’ cream kisses?  I was surprised and elated when I discovered them at the store the other day.  As soon as I saw my favorite Hershey’s candy bar flavor packaged in a kiss, I knew exactly what I had to do with them.  I had to bake them into chocolate blossoms.

     At home, I searched around on the internet until I found a good-looking chocolate blossom recipe.  I went ahead and made a batch of them.  While they were definitely good, they weren’t quite what I wanted.  A did a few tweaks that made them exactly what I had envisioned.

      I melted six ounces of semisweet chocolate chips and stirred two teaspoons of espresso granules into them.  While the chocolate cooled, I creamed the butter and sugars.  Then, I beat in the melted chocolate.  After that, I mixed in the eggs, milk, and vanilla.  Instead of adding a teaspoon of vanilla, I went crazy and added a whole tablespoon (I’m wild like that).

     The above things are the only deviations I made from the recipe.  I will highly suggest, though, that you make the cookies with Dutch processed cocoa powder if you can find it.  I made a batch with natural cocoa powder and a batch with Dutch processed.  The cookies made with Dutch processed cocoa had a smoother, fuller-bodied taste.  The ones made with natural cocoa were still extremely yummy, but they just didn’t have as finished a taste as the other ones.  Either way, though, these cookies are delicious, especially with the sweet, slightly crunchy cookies ‘n’ cream kiss in the center.

Black and Tan Cookies (Two Cookies in One!)

IMG_1300

     Today I want to share a chocolate chip cookie.  No, no, that’s a chocolate chocolate chip cookie.  Wait! Hold on.  It’s both!  Yes, these black and tan cookies are the perfect solution for those indecisive days when it seems almost impossible to choose between wearing a comfy T-shirt or a cute cardigan or either watching a movie or reading a book.  This cookie banishes the either/or and gives you both.

     I have found that sometimes when two food items are combined, the end result is disappointing.  I would have preferred eating the two things separately.  The black and tan cookies banish this problem, too.  These two yummy cookies blend together perfectly.  The richer chocolate base complements the buttery, classic chocolate chip cookie perched on top.

     When I made these, I found that the cookies turned out best when I placed the chocolate base on the cookie sheet and then firmly squished the chocolate chip cookie into the base.  If I just lightly pressed them together, the cookies didn’t really bake up layered.  The top cookie kind of slid off and made a bigger, half-chocolate, half-chocolate chip cookie.  It was still cute, but I personally thought the layered look was a little more elegant.  Plus, with the half-and-half cookie, you don’t get both flavors with each bite.

     For the cookies, I followed the chocolate chip cookie recipe, but I tweaked the double fudge one.  Of course, in the process of cleaning, I believe I told someone to throw a pile of papers away that included the notes.  I’m pretty sure that this is what I did, though,

Chocolate Chocolate Chip (or Double Fudge) Cookie Recipe Adapted from Butter Baking

1 ½ sticks melted butter, melted and cooled but still warm

1 ½ cups packed brown sugar

½ cup granulated sugar

1 egg

1 egg yolk

2 teaspoons vanilla extract

1 tablespoon instant coffee granules or instant espresso powder

1 ½ cups all-purpose flour

½ cup cocoa powder

½ teaspoon baking soda

½ teaspoon salt

1 cup chocolate chips

     In a small bowl, beat the egg and egg yolk together until combined and then sprinkle the coffee granules over it.  Set aside to let the coffee dissolve (not all of it will) while you continue with the dough.

     In a large bowl, mix the butter and sugars together by hand.  Give the egg mixture a good stir to incorporate the coffee and then dump it into the butter-sugar bowl, scraping as much coffee out of the small bowl as possible.  Add the vanilla and stir to combine.

     In a medium bowl, whisk together the dry ingredients.  (If you’re feeling energetic, you can sift the cocoa powder to break up and clumps.  I like doing this, but I have to admit that I didn’t when I made these cookies.  It’s just that the sifter was on the high shelf, and I would have had to get a chair…)

     Add the dry ingredients to the wet and mix until everything is just combined.  Dump the chocolate chips in (and sneak a few for yourself while you’re at it) and give the dough a few final stirs to incorporate.

     After you’ve finished making the dough, just switch back to Natasha’s directions.  By the way, don’t you just love how she styles her blog posts?  Everything always looks so pretty and artistic!  I love the flowers and the little pitcher of milk.  Anyway, these cookies are seriously delicious and really fun to make (and look at) (and eat).  Oh, and I apologize for the rather warm tint of my photo.  It was raining that day, and I had to turn the lights on to take the picture.

Chai-Spice Sugar Cookies

Image

     I’m sorry for the lack of indentations.  I don’t know why, but except for the first paragraph, the indentations won’t show up in the final post.  I’ve tried to edit the post and re-post it, but I can’t figure out how to fix it. 

     Today I have the most amazing cookies to share with you! Okay, so I know that I’m kind of always saying that or something pretty similar about almost every recipe I mention, but somehow it’s always true, especially here! These are chai-spice sugar cookies. As someone who absolutely loves a good chai tea latte, as soon as I saw this recipe, I knew I needed to make it. I would have made it sooner, too, but cardamom isn’t exactly a staple spice in my cabinet.  I had to go to a few stores before I found it at a reasonable price.  (Check out Target.)
These cookies have a soft, slightly chewy texture with a wonderfully warm, subtle, spicy flavor. The spiciness isn’t overwhelming at all, either.  Like I said, the flavor is subtle.
Do you ever eat a cookie that just makes you want to melt from the taste-induced happiness? When I bit into a warm chai cookie, I just wanted to melt blissfully away.  Even though there is nothing like these hot out of the oven, they’re still really yummy cooled off.
Right now, I’m going to urge you, as a friend, to make an extremely profitable investment. Please procure a copy of the Cook’s Illustrated Cookbook for yourself. This is where I found this recipe.  A lot of my absolutely favorite recipes come from this cookbook. I am going to talk about a pumpkin spice cheesecake soon that also came from there. I love this cookbook. It is one of my favorites, and definitely it is my go-to cookbook. There, that’s all I have to say. I’m not a paid advertiser. I’m just a very satisfied consumer.
Oh, and if you do make these, don’t be scared off by the smell of cardamom. I became extremely concerned about the outcome of these cookies when I unscrewed the lid of the cardamom bottle and was overwhelmed by the Pledge-like scent. By the time the dough is all baked up, you won’t be able to detect a whiff of wood cleaner! Your kitchen, instead, will be filled with a warm, autumn, bakery smell. Really, the aroma emanating from your oven is almost as good as the actual taste of the cookies.

P.S. I cheated and used 2% milk instead of whole milk, and the cookies turned out fine.  I just couldn’t bring myself to buy an entire gallon of whole milk just for one tablespoon of it.

Oreo-Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies

IMG_1255

     Let me ask you a question.  What’s the only thing better than a cookie?  How about a cookie with a cookie inside of it?  Yes, I’m talking about the famed Oreo-stuffed chocolate chip cookies!  I’ve seen these cookies on Pinterest and all around the internet.  Now, when I first saw them, I was skeptical about putting a fully baked cookie within a cookie.  That was before I tried double chocolate chunk Oreo cookies, though.  That completely cured me of my doubt about the magic of baking Oreos into cookies.  After trying those, I couldn’t wait to tackle the full-fledged Oreo-stuffed chocolate chip cookies!

       Now, what can I say about these cookies?  They’re delicious.  They’re gigantic (I’m talking in between a golf ball and a tennis ball), and they are fun to eat!  The Oreo-stuffed cookies are also really pretty when you bite into them, and they make people’s eyes pop when you tell them that there is a whole Oreo inside of there.  Fun!